Medium Voltage Switchgear: AIS vs GIS, 12–40.5kV, IEC 62271

15 min read
NAIJI Electric Technical Team
medium voltage switchgearwhat is medium voltagemedium voltage range
Medium Voltage Switchgear: AIS vs GIS, 12–40.5kV, IEC 62271
Table of Contents

Quick Answer: What Is Medium Voltage?

Medium voltage (MV) refers to electrical power systems operating between 1 kV and 35 kV (IEC definition) or 1 kV to 69 kV (IEEE/ANSI definition). It is the voltage class used to distribute power from substations to buildings, factories, and neighborhoods. Medium voltage sits between low voltage (below 1 kV, used inside buildings) and high voltage (above 35-69 kV, used for long-distance transmission). Most industrial and commercial facilities receive power at medium voltage and transform it down to low voltage for use by equipment.

Voltage Range Definitions by Standard

Standard / Region Low Voltage Medium Voltage High Voltage
IEC 60038Up to 1 kV1 kV - 35 kVAbove 35 kV
IEEE / ANSIUp to 1 kV1 kV - 69 kVAbove 69 kV
China (GB)Up to 1 kV1 kV - 40.5 kVAbove 40.5 kV
Europe (CENELEC)Up to 1 kV1 kV - 36 kVAbove 36 kV
US (NEC practice)Up to 1 kV2.4 kV - 69 kVAbove 69 kV

Common Medium Voltage Levels Worldwide

System Voltage Equipment Rating Regions Typical Use
3.3 kV3.6 kVUK, India, older systemsIndustrial motors, mining
6.6 kV7.2 kVUK, India, Japan, miningLarge motors, industrial
10 kV12 kVChina (standard)Urban/rural distribution
11 kV12 kVUK, India, Middle East, AustraliaPrimary distribution
13.8 kV15 kVNorth AmericaDistribution, industrial
20 kV24 kVFrance, Belgium, parts of EuropeDistribution
22 kV24 kVThailand, parts of SE AsiaDistribution
33 kV36 kVUK, India, Middle East, AfricaSub-transmission
35 kV40.5 kVChinaSub-transmission, large industrial

Why Medium Voltage Matters

Medium voltage exists because of a fundamental law: power loss is proportional to the square of the current (Ploss = I²R). By increasing the voltage, the current decreases proportionally, dramatically reducing energy losses and cable costs.

Consider delivering 1 MW of power over 1 km:

Voltage Current Cable Size Power Loss
400 V (LV)1,443 A6 x 300 mm² parallel~80 kW (8%)
10 kV (MV)58 A1 x 25 mm²~3 kW (0.3%)

The MV solution uses a fraction of the cable and wastes far less energy. This is why any facility above approximately 300-500 kW receives power at medium voltage.

Types of Medium Voltage Equipment

Circuit Breakers

MV circuit breakers are the primary protection and switching devices. For a detailed comparison, see our vacuum circuit breaker vs SF6 comparison.

Switchgear

MV switchgear assemblies house breakers, bus bars, disconnectors, and protection relays:

Ring Main Units (RMU)

Ring main units are compact switchgear for underground cable distribution networks, used extensively in urban areas. The XGN15-12 RMU offers modular switch/fuse configurations for flexible network design.

Load Break Switches

SF6 load break switches sectionalize overhead distribution feeders and automate fault isolation. The FZW28-12 boundary switch integrates SF6 insulation with intelligent fault detection for smart grid applications.

Contactors

Vacuum contactors handle frequent switching at medium voltage — motor starting, capacitor bank switching, and transformer energization. Built for high-duty-cycle operations that circuit breakers are not designed for.

Medium Voltage Applications by Industry

Industry Typical MV Voltage Equipment Used
Utility Distribution10-33 kVSwitchgear, RMU, reclosers, pole-mounted VCB
Industrial / Manufacturing6.6-13.8 kVSwitchgear, MCC, VCB, contactors
Commercial (Data Centers, Hospitals)11-13.8 kVCompact switchgear, GIS
Mining6.6-33 kVExplosion-proof switchgear, VCB
Oil & Gas6.6-13.8 kVHazardous area switchgear, generator breakers
Renewable Energy20-35 kVCollector switchgear, transformer protection
Rail Transit10-35 kVTraction substations, GIS
Water / Wastewater6.6-11 kVPump motor starters, VCB, contactors

Medium Voltage Switchgear Selection Criteria

Selecting the right medium voltage switchgear for a project requires evaluating multiple technical and commercial factors. Engineers who rush this decision often end up with equipment that is either over-specified (wasting budget) or under-specified (creating safety hazards). Here is a systematic approach to medium voltage switchgear selection:

Step 1: Determine System Voltage and Fault Level

The first two parameters to establish are the rated voltage and the prospective short-circuit current at the installation point. The rated voltage determines the equipment class (12 kV, 24 kV, or 40.5 kV), and the fault level determines the minimum breaking capacity and short-time withstand rating of the switchgear.

System VoltageEquipment RatingTypical Fault LevelCommon Switchgear
10-11 kV12 kV16-31.5 kAASN3-12, GSN3-12, XGN15-12
20-22 kV24 kV16-25 kAASN2-24, VN2-24E
33-35 kV40.5 kV20-31.5 kAASN1-40.5, GSN1-40.5L, VN1-40.5E

Step 2: Choose Insulation Type

The insulation type has the biggest impact on footprint, cost, and maintenance requirements. For a detailed comparison of all insulation types, see our complete MV switchgear classification guide.

  • Air-insulated (AIS): Lowest cost, largest footprint, needs regular cleaning — best for standard indoor substations with adequate space
  • Gas-insulated (GIS): 50-80% smaller, maintenance-free gas compartment — best for space-constrained, harsh-environment, or critical installations. See where to specify GIS over AIS
  • SF6-free (nitrogen/dry air): Same compact benefits as GIS but with zero greenhouse gas — increasingly required by EU F-Gas Regulation. See SF6-free regulatory compliance guide

Step 3: Define Construction and Arc Safety Requirements

The choice between metal-clad and metal-enclosed construction depends on maintenance practices and safety requirements. For critical substations where operators access compartments during live operation, metal-clad with IAC (Internal Arc Classification) per IEC 62271-200 is essential. For commercial buildings accessed infrequently, metal-enclosed is sufficient and more cost-effective.

Step 4: Evaluate Total Cost of Ownership

Medium voltage switchgear has a 25-30 year service life, so acquisition cost is only 20-30% of total lifecycle cost. Factor in maintenance labor, spare parts, energy losses (bus bar and contact resistance), outage costs from maintenance windows, and end-of-life disposal. SF6-free switchgear often wins the TCO comparison once SF6 gas handling and compliance costs are included.

Medium Voltage Safety: Arc Flash and Protection

Arc flash is the most dangerous hazard in medium voltage switchgear operation. An arc flash event at 12 kV can release energy equivalent to several sticks of dynamite, generating temperatures above 19,000°C and blast pressures that can throw an operator across the room.

Key safety measures for medium voltage switchgear installations:

  • Arc-resistant switchgear: Specify IAC-rated switchgear per IEC 62271-200 Annex A — NAIJI Electric's ASN3-12 is rated IAC-AFLR 50 kA / 1s, redirecting arc energy through pressure-relief channels away from personnel
  • Protection relay coordination: Fast and selective protection relay settings ensure faults are cleared in less than 100ms, limiting arc energy
  • Proper earthing: A well-designed earthing and grounding system limits touch and step voltages during faults to safe levels per IEEE 80
  • Correct short-circuit ratings: Every component must be rated above the prospective fault current — see our guide on how to calculate and specify kA ratings

Medium Voltage Distribution System Topologies

The choice of distribution system topology determines switchgear quantity, configuration, and reliability level. The four main topologies for medium voltage power distribution are:

  • Radial: Simplest and lowest cost — single source, no redundancy. Suitable for small industrial loads where brief outages are acceptable
  • Primary loop (ring): Cable ring with ring main units at each node — provides N-1 redundancy for urban distribution. See MV distribution system design guide
  • Primary selective: Dual source with automatic transfer — standard for hospitals, data centers, continuous process plants
  • Secondary selective: Two transformers feeding two bus sections with bus coupler — highest reliability for critical loads. Requires a dual-bus switchgear lineup

Key Medium Voltage Standards

All medium voltage switchgear must comply with applicable international standards. The IEC 62271 series is the global benchmark, with regional standards (IEEE C37, GB) providing additional or alternative requirements:

  • IEC 62271-200 — Metal-enclosed switchgear (assemblies and panels)
  • IEC 62271-100 — High-voltage circuit breakers (applies to all MV breakers)
  • IEC 62271-203 — Gas-insulated metal-enclosed switchgear (GIS)
  • IEC 60038 — Standard voltages (defines the MV range)
  • IEEE C37.20.2 — Metal-clad switchgear (North America)
  • IEEE C37.20.3 — Metal-enclosed interrupter switchgear
  • GB 3906 — Chinese standard for MV switchgear
  • GB 1984 — Chinese standard for MV circuit breakers

For a detailed breakdown of each IEC 62271 sub-standard and what they mean for switchgear procurement, read our IEC 62271 standard guide. For testing requirements specifically for metal-clad switchgear, see metal-clad switchgear testing procedures.

NAIJI Electric: Full Medium Voltage Product Range

NAIJI Electric manufactures a complete range of medium voltage equipment covering 12 kV to 40.5 kV across 10 product categories and 29 models:

Contact the NAIJI Electric engineering team for product selection, technical specifications, or a project quotation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What voltage range is considered medium voltage?
The exact definition varies by standard. IEC 60038 defines medium voltage as 1 kV to 35 kV. IEEE and ANSI standards consider medium voltage to be 1 kV to 69 kV. In China, the common MV range is 1 kV to 40.5 kV, covering standard voltage levels of 3 kV, 6 kV, 10 kV, 12 kV, 20 kV, 24 kV, 35 kV, and 40.5 kV.
What is the difference between medium voltage and high voltage?
Medium voltage typically ranges from 1 kV to 35-69 kV depending on the standard. High voltage begins above that. MV equipment uses vacuum or SF6 circuit breakers and fits in standard indoor rooms, while HV equipment often requires outdoor substations with much larger clearance distances.
Why is medium voltage used instead of low voltage?
Power loss is proportional to the square of the current (I squared R losses). By stepping up to medium voltage, the same power is transmitted at much lower current, using thinner cables over longer distances with minimal losses. Facilities above approximately 500 kW typically receive power at medium voltage.
What equipment is used at medium voltage?
The main types are: circuit breakers (vacuum or SF6), switchgear (metal-enclosed or gas-insulated), transformers, ring main units (RMUs), load break switches, contactors for motor switching, and current/voltage transformers for measurement and protection.
What are the common medium voltage levels?
The most common levels worldwide are: 3.3 kV (older industrial), 6.6 kV (industrial/mining), 10 kV (China distribution), 11 kV (UK/India/Middle East), 13.8 kV (North America), 20-22 kV (France/SE Asia), 33 kV (sub-transmission), and 35/40.5 kV (China sub-transmission).

Need Help Selecting Switchgear?

Our engineering team can recommend the right products for your project. Get factory-direct pricing from an ISO/CE certified manufacturer.